Review: “Home, I’m Darling” at TimeLine Theatre Co.

Posted

Is it crazy to want to live a life out of the past when, at least in your mind, things were simpler? When people paid more attention to each other rather than their cell phones, when appliances were built to last and clothing was made with hand-crafted details? When, rather than the modern rush, you had time to grow all your own vegetables, make dinner every night, spend lingering evenings with friends?

British playwright Laura Wade’s intriguingly complex dramedy “Home, I’m Darling,” receiving its Chicago premiere at TimeLine Theatre, contemplates nostalgia taken to its most extreme, and, perhaps as expected, mostly imploding.

The opening scene shows us a world out of 1950s television perfection. Meticulously-coiffed housewife Judy (Claire Kaplan) joyfully prepares her husband Johnny’s (Elliot Sagay) breakfast. Over apparently transcendent toast and homemade marmalade, they chat about how blissfully content they are: “appallingly happy,” Johnny insists.

“Home, I’m Darling”

When: Through Dec. 13
Where: TimeLine Theatre Co. (5035 N. Broadway.)
Info: Tickets from $40; run time is 2 hour and 25 minutes with one intermission

After he leaves for work, lunchbox and briefcase in hand, the wife sits down at the kitchen table and pulls out her laptop.

Judy wants to live in the ‘50s, or at least her idealized version of them. After getting laid off from her job in finance, she implored and convinced Johnny to give that a genuine shot, even though it’s the 21st century (the play was written in 2018 and won London’s Olivier Award for Best New Comedy). The laptop? Well, it’s simply a necessary exception to source all those vintage items for their home décor and wardrobe. It’s also very useful for finding the like-minded.

Once we discover the concept, some predictable conflicts arise. It sure is tough living on one income in the modern economy, even with homegrown veggies, and even without kids. Judy’s mother, the practical and mildly bohemian Sylvia (Janet Ulrich Brooks), who unlike Judy lived through the ‘50s, vociferously disapproves of trying to re-create an era she and other women worked hard to revolutionize. A twist emerges when Judy discovers that Johnny’s boss Alex (Gloria Imseih Petrelli) — surprise, surprise — is a woman.

Judy (Claire Kaplan, far right) and Johnny (Elliot Sagay, far left) enjoy an evening with friends Fran (Maya Rowe, center right) and Marcus (Brandon Dahlquist, center left) in TimeLine Theatre Company’s production of Laura Wade’s Home, I’m Darling.

From left to right: Elliot Sagay, Brandon Dahlquist, Maya Rowe and Claire Kaplan respectively portray Johnny, Marcus, Fran and Judy in “Home, I’m Darling” at TimeLine Theatre Co.

Courtesy of Brett Beiner

The sexual politics and dynamics certainly get a good and amusing working over, particularly when Wade introduces another couple, Fran (Maya Rowe) and Marcus (Brandon Dahlquist). They’re tempted to enter this way of living themselves, but we begin to wonder whether that’s mostly just because Fran loves the clothes and wishes her house was cleaner and Marcus wishes… Well, let’s just say the ‘50s norms had many advantages for men — at least for white men — the lack of certain employment laws being one of them. These observations make for entertaining scenes, but are glaringly obvious.

The show reaches more interesting terrain when Johnny begins to wonder about how others view him being dedicatedly served a gimlet and slippers when he comes home, and especially when Judy contemplates how far she’d really go to maintain this life, even after her near-delusional gloss on the ‘50s past is exposed. It’s the depth of her quirky desire, and the explored-but-never-fully-resolved reasons for it, that give the work psychological dimension.

The scenes range in tone, sometimes within moments, from stylized comedy-of-manners to comic-cringey to debate drama to sequences of motivational probing worthy of a couple’s therapy session. The variation makes this play a bit hard to settle into.

Some of the off-kilter qualities are unquestionably intentional on both Wade’s and director Mechelle Moe’s part — they both embrace letting the play wander across genres. But in TimeLine’s take, I think some of it also comes from this being an American production of a British play.

Judy (Claire Kaplan, right) and her mother, Sylvia (Janet Ulrich Brooks), discuss nostalgia in TimeLine Theatre Company’s production of Laura Wade’s Home, I’m Darling.

Janet Ulrich Brooks (left) portrays Judy’s mother in “Home, I’m Darling.”

Courtesy of Brett Beiner

The ‘50s, and the meaning of them, were not identical in the US and the UK; post-war meant something very different in physically battered Europe. English manners had, and still have, an even heavier, obligatory refinement. Wade is clearly a stickler for language, and although the accents here are all strong enough and the actors gifted, the rhythm of the dialogue, the placement and length of ripe pauses, require more surgical precision to hit their full effect. You can tell because sometimes they do work completely, particularly when Rowe is involved.

But even when not hitting all its moments, this production sure serves as pleasing eye candy. Every inch of set designer Courtney O’Neill’s set has mid-century flair, from the sun-colored kitchen to the texture of the upholstery. And Christine Pascual’s costumes have a big role to play here, especially since Moe chooses to have the very poised and likable Kaplan change them onstage between scenes.

This retro-fantasy of a world indeed comes off as a legitimate time capsule. And that’s both as enjoyable as it is essential, as the biggest driving question underneath “Home, I’m Darling” is why Judy so very desperately longs to enclose herself in it.